An analysis of platos concept of ultimate happiness
Ferrari, G. Holism Any discussion of holism and related issues is made difficult by the lack of a philosophical consensus on what the issues are, or even how terms should be used.
Anagnostopoulos, Mariana. Justice will be what remains once they find the other three virtues in it, namely wisdom, courage, and moderation a.
Socrates points out that the aim is to make the whole city, and not any particular class, as happy as possible b. Somehow the ensuing argument is supposed to show why that would be a bad idea.
Book VII Socrates continues his discussion of the philosopher and the Forms with a third analogy, the analogy of the cave ac. But as long as this negative or other-worldly attitude towards the physical side of human nature prevails, no interest is to be expected on the part of Plato in nature as a whole — let alone in the principles of the cosmic order but cf.
Bobonich, Christopher. Against this bleak backdrop the optimistic Socrates enters the picture. Moreover, considering it a political work would be somewhat mistaken.
This applies in particular to concepts like the good and the just, as witnessed by the wide disagreement about their nature a—c. We take ourselves, then, to be fashioning the happy city, not picking out a few happy people and putting them in it, but making the whole city happy.
The doctrine implied by Plato's remarks at c5-d is similar, though less explicit.
This is a claim about Socrates' philosophical activity, and is not, or at least not directly, a claim about the aims of a city or its rulers. But the basic institutions of the polis, which determine the politi- cal, legal, and administrative framework within which citizens live their lives and interact with each other, are structural properties. Socrates proceeds to discuss the living and housing conditions of the guardians: they will not have private property, they will have little privacy, they will receive what they need from the city via taxation of the other classes, and they will live communally and have common messes ee. The misuse of rhetoric is exemplified by the speech attributed to the orator Lysias, a somewhat contrived plea to favor a non-lover rather than a lover. Thus as I use the term, if there are no objective values, there is no such thing as well-being. Too much luxury makes the oligarchs soft and the poor revolt against them c-e. That the Good is nowhere subjected to such treatment must be due to the enormity of the task involved in undertaking a systematic identification of all that is good, and in distinguishing good things from each other, as well as from the Form of the Good. If it is primarily about ethics then perhaps its recognition as a seminal political work is unwarranted. One strategy taken by commentators on this passage is to stress that, under the circumstances, the alternative for a person who is required by the city to give up philosophy for management is to refuse to obey, thereby acting unjustly and abandoning virtue. Xenophon Memorabilia I, 10; Glaucon tells the fable of the Ring of Gyges, which, like the One Ring in the Lord of the Rings, has the power to make its wearer invisible. The philosopher is at the pinnacle of this pursuit: having cast off the blinders of ignorance, he can now explore the higher realm of truth, and this experience makes every merely physical pleasure pale in comparison. The Analogy of the City and the Soul The analogy of the city and the soul, is Socrates proposed and accepted method by which to argue that the just person is better off than the unjust person Book II, ca. If the connection is made strong enough, cases like Stilpo will be impossible.
based on 90 review